Choosing Durable Roofing for Hail-Prone Areas: A Complete Guide


Hailstorms may rain small stones to giant pieces of ice, which can easily damage the roof. Poor roofing may lead to massive destruction. After hailstorms, critical issues such as leaks, cracks and even structural problems can occur. So, when looking for roofing material for roof leak repair Winnipeg, keep in mind that it is not only about how they look from the street but also about protecting your home against such natural disasters.

Hailstorms are common in Manitoba, especially in recent years. For example, the Manitoba Agricultural Services Corporation stated receiving about 1900 hail claims in one year. This is higher than the total for the last two years.

The frequency of hailstorms shows a marked rise in roof damage by the storms. For residents and businessmen in Manitoba, selecting materials that can resist hailstone impacts is not only an issue of resilience but also a question of safety.

Being able to design hail-resistant roof, you also have to know what characteristics define an efficient and resilient one. Other significant factors are the choice of impact-resistant materials, appropriate installation degree and strength levels in regards to material durability as well as roof slope. These elements fortify your house to withstand the unpredictable ravages of hailstorms.

This article will guide you in selecting the most appropriate roofing material to build houses in hail-sensitive areas based on durability and affordability, environmental impact and appearance. It will help you make the right decision by providing proper information so that your home’s roof not only appears attractive but also strong enough to resist hailstorms.


Roofing for Hail

Understanding Hail Impact on Roofs

Hail can vary greatly in size and impact. Hail vary from soft hail or graupel, which generally does not damage roofs, to large hailstones that can cause substantial damage. The nature of hail and its formation process is critical to understanding its potential impact on roofing materials.

Common Types of Damage Caused by Hail

Loss of Asphalt Granules

Hail impact frequently leads to the loss of granules off asphalt shingles. The bottom asphalt layer may be exposed. This loss affects the ability of the roof to be waterproof and safeguarded.

Visible Cracks in Granules

Asphalt shingles can present a recognizable pattern of divots or radial cracks, stemming from the point of impact caused by hailstones. Hailstorms accompanied by high wind speeds can enhance this damage, producing noticeable cracks.

Exposed and Cracked Asphalt Coating

Once the protective granules are loosened, whatever is underneath – be it an asphalt coating or fiberglass mat-will come into direct contact with the elements that can cause additional wear and tear over time including cracking.

Dents and Bruising

The different roofing materials like metal and slate can be visibly dented, bruised or even punctured by hailstones. These impacts impair the structural integrity of a roofing material.

Broken or Cracked Shingles

More significant hailstones can rip or destroy roof shingles and thus require prompt repairs replacements in order to avoid leakage of water into the building.

Damage to Roof Accessories

Hail damage is also vulnerable in elements such as gutters, vents, skylights and flashing. Hail may also lead to dents, loosen parts and even break skylights or windows.

Premature Aging of Shingles

Hailstones even smaller than those that contribute to obvious damage can cause premature aging of the shingles because such impact shortens durability and performance in general concerning the roof’s lifespan.

Roof Hail damage is not obvious sometimes, especially if hailstones are small. However, hail impacts on the roof affect it even at minor levels, which eventually results in severe damage over time.

Hence, regular checks are necessary, particularly after hailstorms to detect and then rectify the damage as soon as possible. When conducting comprehensive assessments of and decisions regarding repairs, it is recommended to seek advice from professionals experienced in Winnipeg roof repair.

Winnipeg Shingles


Key Factors for Selecting Hail-Resistant Roofs

There are several key factors to consider when choosing a durable roofing material in hail-prone areas that would provide the maximum protection and lifespan of your projects.

  1. Impact-Resistant Materials: The selection of material is vital for hail protection. Some of these options include the use of impact-resistant shingles, metal roofing and even synthetic materials such as rubber or plastic. Metal roofing Winnipeg often provides high hail performance because it is very durable and hail impacts are absorbed well. Asphalt shingles provide average performance in terms of hail, while synthetic materials’ performance depends on their composition and design.


  1. Proper Installation: Installing a hail-resistant roof is highly dependent on how effective it can be. Reputable and experienced roofing contractors guarantee that the materials are properly anchored so they can survive impact due to hail. Incorrect installation can weaken the structure’s durability making it prone during hailstorm events.


  1. Material Durability: Hail –resistance is important for durability. Strong, durable and long lasting materials such as high quality and impact-resistant shingles or metal roofs are known the withstand hailstones well.


  1. Roof Pitch: The resilience to hail damage depends on the slope of roof. There is a reduced damage potential as hailstones will bounce off rather than hitting directly if the pitch of the roof is steeper. A steeper pitch on the roof can aid in overall hail resistance, however, it is not a guarantee of no damage from hails.


  1. Regular Maintenance: Another thing that should be done to preserve the resilience of a hail-resistant roof is regular maintenance and timely repairs. This includes checking the roof for hail damages and signs of wear, as well as hiring professional roofer to make repairs or replacements where necessary.


  1. Impact Ratings and Testing Standards: Understanding impact ratings and testing standards, such as UL 2218 and FM 4473, is paramount. These standards involve controlled impact tests that simulate hailstone force, grading materials on a scale of Class 1 to 4 for impact resistance. Materials conforming to these standards offer a tangible advantage in hail resistance​​.


  1. Local Climate and Hail Frequency: Consider the local weather conditions and hailstorm prevalence. In areas prone to severe hailstorms, the need for investing inhail-resistant roofing becomes even more important. Hail resistant materials can protect properties from possible damage caused by hails.


  1. Cost and Insurance Considerations: Factor in both the initial cost and potential long-term savings. Hail-resistant materials may involve a higher upfront investment but can reduce the need for frequent repairs and associated costs. Many insurance providers offer discounts on premiums for homes with hail-resistant roofs​​.


  1. Roofing Material Options: Metal roofing is a top choice for its durability and excellent hail resistance, though it involves a higher initial investment. Synthetic polymers provide high impact resistance and flexibility but tend to be costlier than traditional asphalt shingles. Asphalt shingles, widely available and cost-effective, offer enhanced impact-resistant variants but have moderate impact resistance compared to other alternatives​​​​​​.
  2. Panel Design and Thickness in Metal Roofing: When choosing a metal roof, consider the panel’s gauge (thickness), tensile strength, UL Impact rating, and design. (PAC-CLAD Full Line Catalog: Metal Wall Panel & Roof Systems, n.d.). Thicker steel panels provide better protection against large-sized hailstones. A higher tensile strength holds up better to dents and surface damage, and a UL 2218 Class 4 rating indicates the highest level of impact resistance for metal roofing panels​​.

Hence, selecting a hail-resistant roof involves a comprehensive evaluation of materials, installation quality, maintenance practices, and local climate considerations. By carefully considering these factors, homeowners can choose a roofing solution that offers enhanced protection against hail, ensuring the longevity and integrity of their home’s roofing system.

Comparative Analysis of Roofing Materials

You need to select the right roofing material for hail-prone areas through an expert-level understanding of the options available.

Here’s a comparative analysis of several roofing materials based on their hail resistance, durability, cost, and other considerations.

Metal Roofing

Asphalt Shingles

Cedar Roofing

Synthetic Slate and Copper Roofing

EPDM Rubber and Natural Slate

Selecting a roofing material for hail-prone areas is a careful balancing act. It’s crucial to weigh hail resistance against durability, aesthetics, and financial considerations. Each material has its unique merits and potential drawbacks, and the right choice often depends on individual needs, climate conditions, and long-term goals.

Impact Resistance Ratings and Insurance Considerations


Impact Resistance Ratings: The UL 2218 Standard

In hail-prone areas, it is important to understand the ratings of impact resistance when considering roofing options. Roofing materials in UL 2108 are rated from Class I to Class IV with respect of the level of resistance during a simulation test that involves dropping a steel ball through them. 4th class is the top rating which implies a very strong resistance to hail impact. This test measures the ability of a roofing material at its weakest points such as edges and corners.

Types of Impact-Resistant Roofing Materials


  1. Modified Asphalt Shingles: These shingles, like the GAF Timberline ArmorShield II, utilize a modified asphalt formula, providing rubber-like flexibility and maximum impact resistance while retaining the appearance of traditional shingles​​.
  2. Certainteed Landmark IR and Owens Corning TruDefinition Duration STORM: These shingles are designed to resist hail damage with added durable reinforcement. They also feature enhanced sealants and granule adhesion to withstand severe weather​​.
  3. Malarkey Legacy Shingles: Fortified with polymer-modified asphalt technology, these shingles offer greater granule adhesion and hail resistance​​.

Insurance Considerations

Installing Class 4 impact-resistant roofing materials can help homeowners in hail-prone areas. Many insurance companies offer discounts on their homeowners’ insurance premiums, sometimes even by up to 20 percent for these high-rated materials in properties. So, homeowners should inquire about those discounts with the insurance provider.

Selecting roofing materials that have a high UL 2218 impact rating not only ensures better protection against hail damage, but such an option can also result in substantial savings on insurance premiums. To obtain the best materials for their specific needs and professional installation in terms of hail resistance, homeowners should consult with roofing professionals.

Practical Tips for Selecting Durable Roofing in Hail-Prone Areas

For areas suffering from hail, many factors should be considered when choosing roofing materials to make sure they will last and fulfill your requirements. Here are some practical tips to guide your decision:


The cost of roofing materials ranges from very low to high. Set a budget is good but also look at the long-term aspects. Cheaper materials may need more maintenance, and thus higher costs can accumulate over time.


Roofing material also largely depends on the local climate. There is a need for materials that stand up to high rainfall or snowfall, which includes metal and asphalt shingles. Regions with high heat and humidity may need materials that prevent molding or mildew like clay tiles.

Aesthetic Appeal

Your home’s curb appeal is significantly affected by the roof. Select materials that go well with your home’s style and architectural designs. This encompasses the natural appearance of cedar shingles and even the smoothness of metal roofs, which ensures your home looks good while being resistant to hail damage.

Durability and Maintenance

The hail-prone areas require roofing with high durability. Materials such as metal roofing Winnipeg and slate tiles provide excellent durability and Longevity. Also, consider maintenance, because some materials require more attention than others.

Energy Efficiency

In hail-prone areas, homeowners must make sure to choose energy-efficient roofing. Such roofs, like cool roofs, green roofs and solar rooftops work following the mechanism of lowering down reflectance from sunlight as well as absorbing less radiation. This can significantly reduce energy bills and boost sustainability.

Air conditioning needs have been drastically reduced by energy-efficient roofs that make use of light colour materials or surfaces coated with reflective silicon. Further, various types of roofing materials such as metal, slates and terra cotta give varied energy saving capabilities and life span.

Winnipeg residents should consider these options when looking for strong and efficient solutions to roofing that is durable against hail as the weather can be severe in such zones. So asking professional roofing contractors such as Kenava Roofing can enlighten how the best material and mount should be.

Professional Consultation

For the best solution, get advice from professional roofers. They can provide personalized recommendations according to your house’s structure, area climate and individual tastes. You will be guided through the selection process by a professional, based on performance features of materials; cost and maintenance needs.

Kenava Roofing provides professional advice and installation services for homeowners in Winnipeg. They know the peculiarities of local weather and how different roofing material will affect your house. If you require a new roof in Winnipeg, repairs or inspection Kenava Roofing offers trustworthy and competent services all-year round.

Call Kenava Roofing today and invest in a roofing solution that brings long term benefits to your home.


PAC-CLAD Full Line Catalog: Metal Wall Panel & Roof Systems. (n.d.). PAC-CLAD | Petersen. Retrieved January 12, 2024, from


Kim, J.-J. (2015). Qualities, Use, and Examples of Sustainable Building Materials. 146.201.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *